AI Mental Health App: Can AI Therapy for Depression Really Help?
- James Colley
- Sep 17
- 4 min read
Depression can drain energy, narrow perspective, and make everyday life feel impossible. While traditional treatments—like cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), interpersonal therapy, and medication—remain highly effective, barriers such as cost, waitlists, and stigma leave many without support.
This is where AI therapy for depression steps in. By delivering structured, evidence-based interventions through apps and digital platforms, AI has the potential to make support more accessible, affordable, and consistent.
In this article, we’ll explore the benefits, limitations, privacy concerns, affordability, and case studies of AI mental health apps, while showing how therappai takes a video-first approach to support. For broader context, see our guide to the future of AI therapy.
What is “AI Therapy” for Depression?
AI therapy uses artificial intelligence to guide structured interventions—usually CBT—via chatbots, video avatars, or interactive self-help programs. Typical features include:
Guided CBT flows: capturing automatic thoughts, spotting distortions, reframing, and planning small actions (behavioral activation).
Personalized recommendations: tailored to mood check-ins and progress.
Skill coaching: breathing, grounding, and progressive muscle relaxation.
Progress tracking: mood trends and habit adherence displayed over time.
Health systems like the UK’s NHS have begun evaluating digitally enabled therapies to extend reach and free clinician hours for more complex cases (NICE).
What the Evidence Says CBT Works for Depression
CBT is one of the most researched psychotherapies for depression. An umbrella analysis published in JAMA Psychiatry (2025) found CBT to be probably effective for major depressive disorder and several other conditions (JAMA Psychiatry).
Because CBT is structured and replicable, AI can reliably deliver its building blocks—helping people practice between sessions or when therapists aren’t available.
Digital CBT (iCBT) is Effective
A large individual-patient-data network meta-analysis in JAMA Psychiatry showed that guided internet-based CBT outperformed unguided formats for moderate-to-severe depression. For mild depression, unguided iCBT performed comparably to in-person therapy (JAMA Psychiatry).
Early Trials of AI Chatbots Are Promising
A 2025 randomized trial of a generative AI therapy chatbot (Therabot) found significant reductions in depression and anxiety symptoms, with guardrails and human oversight built in (Dartmouth College). Other studies suggest AI chatbots can reduce symptoms in the short term, but research is still emerging.
Digital Tools Can Help During Wait Times
A 2024 trial in JAMA Network Open compared three popular mental health apps and found all reduced depression and anxiety, with no one app superior. The takeaway: structured digital tools can provide meaningful relief while people wait for therapy (JAMA Network Open).
Benefits of AI Therapy for Depression
Accessibility & Speed
Available anytime, anywhere—no waitlists. Digital therapies can free up therapist time and extend reach (NICE).
Structured Skills On Demand
AI excels at guiding CBT’s step-by-step logic: reframes, behavioral activation, and evidence testing (JAMA Psychiatry).
Affordability & Cost-Effectiveness
Studies show internet-based CBT is often cost-effective, sometimes even “highly likely” to be cost-effective, compared to waitlists or usual care (JAMA Network Open; JMIR).
Measurement-Based Care
Apps can visualize mood improvements linked to specific practices, reinforcing consistency and supporting blended care (JAMA Network Open).
Limitations & Risks
Not a Replacement for Clinicians: Complex depression often requires human input and sometimes medication. Guidance improves outcomes (JAMA Psychiatry).
Evidence Is Uneven: Strong for digital CBT; still early for AI chatbots (NEJM AI).
Privacy Concerns: Reports show many mental health apps share or misuse sensitive data. Mozilla’s Privacy Not Included project flagged major weaknesses (Mozilla Foundation).
Regulatory Cautions: The NHS and media have warned against framing general-purpose chatbots as therapy substitutes (Guardian).
Skills AI Mental Health Apps Teach
Behavioral activation: scheduling small, rewarding tasks.
Cognitive restructuring: reframing negative automatic thoughts.
Breathing & PMR: calming physiology to reduce stress.
Lifestyle routines: sleep, exercise, and daily structure.
These skills mirror CBT and are core to long-term recovery.
How to Choose the Best AI Mental Health App
Checklist:
✅ CBT structure and thought records
✅ Clear crisis boundaries (not for emergencies)
✅ Privacy protections (encryption, data export/delete)
✅ Guidance options if needed
✅ Transparent outcomes and published results
✅ Affordable and easy to use
Case Studies & Evidence Signals
Guided vs. Unguided iCBT: Guided is better for moderate-to-severe depression (JAMA Psychiatry).
Therabot Trial: AI chatbot reduced depression and anxiety symptoms with oversight (Dartmouth College).
During Waitlists: Multiple apps reduced symptoms while patients waited (JAMA Network Open).
Cost-Effectiveness: iCBT delivers more QALYs at acceptable costs (JAMA Network Open).
Privacy: What Good Looks Like
End-to-end encryption
Data minimization
Export/delete controls
No third-party advertising links
Mozilla’s independent reviews highlight why these safeguards matter (Mozilla Foundation).
How therappai Supports Depression
therappai focuses on video-first AI therapy combined with evidence-based CBT flows:
Video AI Sessions: Human-like interactions guide CBT steps and skills.
Crisis Buddy: Pre-crisis support with grounding and safety plans.
Insights & Milestones: Dashboards show patterns (e.g., sleep and mood links).
Privacy Controls: Delete/export options to keep user data safe.
Explore more in our guide.
Final words
AI therapy for depression is not a silver bullet, but it offers real, evidence-backed support: accessibility, structured CBT skills, affordability, and progress tracking. For many, AI apps can bridge the gap while waiting for therapy—or provide ongoing daily reinforcement.
For severe or complex depression, human care remains essential. Choose AI tools that emphasize privacy, transparency, and evidence. For the most advanced video-first approach, explore therappai.
References
Comments